Study finds link between sitting all day and risk of dying from cancer


That study had enrolled a multiracial group of more than 30,000 middle-aged and older men and women and, starting in 2002, gathered details about their health, lifestyle and medical conditions. Some of those volunteers also agreed to wear an activity tracker for about a week, to objectively record how often and vigorously they moved and how much they sat.

Now, the researchers gathered the records for about 8000 of the volunteers who had worn a tracker at some point. These men and women were at least 45 years old when they joined the study, with health ranging from good to iffy. Some were overweight, smokers, diabetic or had high blood pressure or other conditions. Others were relatively lean, and some reported that they exercised regularly.

The researchers checked the data from these volunteers’ activity trackers, noting how many hours per day, on average, they objectively had spent unmoving. Most were quite sedentary. As a group, they had spent about 13 of their 16 waking hours most days in a chair or otherwise inactive.

Getting up and walking around the living room for a few minutes every hour or so could make a meaningful difference.

Dr Susan Gilchrist

But there were differences. Some people had been up and moving rather often, either completing light-intensity activities like strolling, housecleaning and gardening or actively exercising, according to the readouts from their activity trackers (which measured how many — or few — steps they took every minute).

The researchers divided the volunteers into thirds, based on how much daily time they spent sitting. Then they checked death records for everyone, looking to see who might have passed away recently from any type of cancer.

Finally, they examined whether, statistically, sitting more increased the likelihood of dying from cancer. The men and women in the group that had spent the most hours sitting were 82 per cent more likely to have died from cancer during the study’s follow-up period than those in the group that had sat the least. This association held true when the researchers controlled for people’s ages, weight, gender, health, smoking status, education, geographic location and other factors.


But the scientists noted a more-encouraging finding when they statistically modelled how those risks might change if someone, theoretically, started moving more. In those models, for every 30 minutes that someone exercised instead of continuing to sit, the risk of later dying from cancer fell by 31 per cent. Even if someone did not formally work out, but substituted at least 10 minutes of his or her usual sitting time with gentle strolling, housework, gardening or other light-intensity activities, the risk of dying from cancer fell by about 8 per cent.

Taken as a whole, these data suggest that “even a small amount of extra physical activity, no matter how light it might be, can have benefits for cancer survival,” said Dr Susan Gilchrist, a cardiologist at the MD Anderson Cancer Centre who works with cancer patients and led the new study.

The study has many limitations, though. It looked at cancer mortality, not the risk of developing the disease in the first place, and lumped all cancer types together. Perhaps most important, this kind of prospective study is not a randomised experiment and cannot tell us that sitting more causes increased cancer mortality, only that the two are linked. It also offers no clues about how sitting raises that risk, and whether inactivity directly changes our bodies or if other factors, including what we eat or drink while seated, influence how sitting raises our risk of dying from cancer.

Gilchrist said she and her colleagues hoped to examine some of those issues in future studies. But even with the caveats, she thinks that the data from this study should be rousing.

“The tangible takeaway is that we can tell people they do not have to go out and run a marathon” to potentially reduce their risk of dying from cancer, she said. “It looks like just getting up and walking around the living room for a few minutes every hour or so could make a meaningful difference.”

New York Times

Get our Morning & Evening Edition newsletters

Most Viewed in Lifestyle